Quantitative Models for Distinguishing Punctuated and Continuous-Time Models of Character Evolution and Their Implications for Macroevolutionary Theory

Abstract

AbstractThe recent proliferation of quantitative models for assessing anatomical character evolution all assume that character change happens continuously through time. However, punctuated equilibrium model posits that character change should be coincide with cladogenetic events, and thus should be tied to origination rates. Rates of cladogenesis are important to quantitative phylogenetics, but typically only for establishing prior probabilities of phylogenetic topologies. Here, we modify existing character likelihood models to use the local cladogenesis rates from Bayesian analyses to generate the amounts of character change over time dependent on origination rates, as expected under the punctuated equilibrium model. In the case of strophomenoid brachiopods strop from the Ordovician, we find that Bayesian analyses strongly favor punctuated models over continuous-time models, with elevated rates of cladogenesis early in the clade’s history inducing frequencies of change despite constant rates of change per speciation event. This corroborates prior work proposing that the early burst in strophomenoid disparity reflects simply elevated speciation rates,which in turnhas implications for seemingly unrelated macroevolutionary theory about whether early bursts reflect shifts in intrinsic constraints or empty ecospace. Future development of punctuated character evolution models should account for the full durations of species, which will provide a test of continuous change rates. Ultimately, continuous change vs. punctuated change should become part of phylogenetic paleobiology in the same way that other tests of character evolution currently are.Non-technical SummaryPunctuated Equilibrium predicts a distribution of anatomical change that is fundamentally different from the models used in studies of relationships among species. We present a model to assess relationships that assumes punctuated change. We apply this model to a dataset of strophomenoid brachiopods to demonstrate that a model of punctuated change fits better than a model of continuous-time (“phyletic gradualism”) change in this group. Notably, because the punctuated model posits elevated speciation rates early in the strophomenoid history, the model also posits elevated rates of change among the early strophomenoids relative to later ones. This corroborates notions for what causes bursts of anatomical evolution rooted in ecological theory rather than evolutionary developmental theory. More basically, it emphasizes that paleontologists should consider both punctuated and continuous-time models when assessing relationships and other aspects of macroevolutionary theory.