Genetics, energetics and allostery during a billion years of hydrophobic protein core evolution

Abstract

AbstractProtein folding is driven by the burial of hydrophobic amino acids in a tightly-packed core that excludes water. The genetics, biophysics and evolution of hydrophobic cores are not well understood, in part because of a lack of systematic experimental data on sequence combinations that do - and do not - constitute stable and functional cores. Here we randomize protein hydrophobic cores and evaluate their stability and function at scale. The data show that vast numbers of amino acid combinations can constitute stable protein cores but that these alternative cores frequently disrupt protein function because of allosteric effects. These strong allosteric effects are not due to complicated, highly epistatic fitness landscapes but rather, to the pervasive nature of allostery, with many individually small energy changes combining to disrupt function. Indeed both protein stability and ligand binding can be accurately predicted over very large evolutionary distances using additive energy models with a small contribution from pairwise energetic couplings. As a result, energy models trained on one protein can accurately predict core stability across hundreds of millions of years of protein evolution, with only rare energetic couplings that we experimentally identify limiting the transplantation of cores between highly diverged proteins. Our results reveal the simple energetic architecture of protein hydrophobic cores and suggest that allostery is a major constraint on sequence evolution.