Erroneous compensation for long-latency feedback delays as origin of Essential Tremor

Abstract

AbstractEssential tremor (ET), a movement disorder characterized by involuntary oscillations of the limbs during movement, remains to date not well understood. It has been recently suggested that the tremor originates from impaired delay compensation, affecting movement representation and online control. Here we tested this hypothesis directly with ET patients (N=24) and neurologically intact (NI) volunteers (N=28) in an upper limb postural perturbation task. After maintaining their hand in a visual target, participants experienced perturbations of unpredictable direction and magnitude, and were instructed to counter the perturbation and steer their hand back to the starting position. In comparison with NI volunteers, ET patients early muscular responses (Short and Long Latency Responses, 20-50 ms and 50-100 ms respectively) were preserved or even slightly increased. However, they exhibited perturbation-dependent deficits when stopping and stabilizing their hand in the final target supporting the hypothesis that the tremor was generated by the feedback controller. We show in a computational model that errors in delay compensation accumulating over time produced the same small increase in initial feedback response followed by oscillations that scaled with the perturbation magnitude as observed in ET population. Our experimental results therefore validate the computational hypothesis that inaccurate delay compensation in long-latency pathways could be the origin of the tremor.Significance StatementEssential Tremor origin remains poorly understood. In the present study, we focused on motor impairments associated with feedback control. Following a mechanical perturbation applied to their arm, patients’ short and initial long latency stretch responses were preserved. However, we observed clear impairments during the stabilization phase that scaled with the perturbation magnitude. These results were reproduced in a computational model where delay compensation was inaccurate, suggesting that the origin of the tremor may lie in an underestimation of the delays impacting the internal monitoring of the motor commands.