Unusual migratory strategy a key factor driving interactions at wind energy facilities in at-risk bats

Abstract

AbstractSeasonal movement strategies are poorly understood for most animals, impeding broader understanding of processes underlying migration and limiting practical conservation needs. Here we develop and implement a framework for integrating multiple sources of endogenous markers, in particular stable hydrogen isotope data, that capture and scale dynamics from the movements of individuals to that of continental migration. We assembled and integrated thousands of new isotopic measurements from bat fur with existing datasets and applied this framework to reveal migratory patterns of three broadly distributed bat species most at risk for fatalities at wind energy facilities. Our findings show that the species comprising the lowest proportion of wind turbine fatalities (silver-haired bats) exhibits expected movements to lower latitudes in autumn and higher latitudes in spring. Surprisingly, the two species with higher wind turbine fatality rates (hoary and eastern red bats) have more complex movements, including significant movement to higher latitudes during autumn. We term this unique strategy “pell-mell” migration, during which some individuals are as likely to move to higher latitudes as lower latitudes, relative to their individual summering grounds, in early autumn, after which they move to similar or lower latitudes to overwinter. The pell-mell migratory period corresponds with peak fatalities at wind energy facilities, and bats moving northward during autumn are associated with mortality at those facilities. Our results provide direct support for the hypothesis that bat fatalities at wind energy facilities are related to migration and highlight the importance of migratory distance as an ultimate driver of increased interactions with wind energy facilities, which appears significantly greater for species that travel widely across latitudes in the autumn.