Prediction of local convergent shifts in evolutionary rates with phyloConverge characterizes the phenotypic associations and modularity of regulatory elements

Abstract

AbstractPhysiological and morphological adaptations to extreme environments arise from the molecular evolution of protein-coding regions and regulatory elements (REs) that regulate gene expression. Comparative genomics methods can characterize genetic elements that underlie the organism-level adaptations, but convergence analyses of REs are often limited by their evolutionary properties. A RE can be modularly composed of multiple transcription factor binding sites (TFBS) that may each experience different evolutionary pressures. The modular composition and rapid turnover of TFBS also enables a compensatory mechanism among nearby TFBS that allows for weaker sequence conservation/divergence than intuitively expected. Here, we introduce phyloConverge, a comparative genomics method that can perform fast, fine-grained local convergence analysis of genetic elements. phyloConverge calibrates for local shifts in evolutionary rates using a combination of maximum likelihood-based estimation of nucleotide substitution rates and phylogenetic permutation tests. Using the classical convergence case of mammalian adaptation to subterranean environments, we validate that phyloConverge identifies rate-accelerated conserved non-coding elements (CNEs) that are strongly correlated with ocular tissues, with improved specificity compared to competing methods. We use phyloConverge to perform TFBS-scale and nucleotide-scale scoring to dissect each CNE into subregions with uneven convergence signals and demonstrate its utility for understanding the modularity and pleiotropy of REs. Subterranean-accelerated regions are also enriched for molecular pathways and TFBS motifs associated with neuronal phenotypes, suggesting that subterranean eye degeneration may coincide with a remodeling of the nervous system. phyloConverge offers a rapid and accurate approach for understanding the evolution and modularity of regulatory elements underlying phenotypic adaptation.