Comparison of the surgical and follow-up costs associated with microsurgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma

Abstract

Object The best approach to the management of vestibular schwannoma (VS) remains controversial. The aim of this study is to analyze the initial and follow-up costs of resection and stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with VS. Methods Initial and follow-up costs in 53 cases in which patients with unilateral, previously unoperated VSs > 3 cm underwent resection (21 cases) or radiosurgery (32 cases) at the Mayo Clinic from June 2000 until July 2002 were analyzed for 36 months. Follow-up treatment-specific utilization records were gathered prospectively for patients not returning to the Mayo Clinic after treatment. Six-month moving averages of incremental follow-up costs were calculated for the 2 patient groups. Results The mean cost of surgery in the microsurgery group was $23,788 (95% confidence interval $22,280–$24,842) compared with $16,143 (95% confidence interval $15,277–$17,545) for the radiosurgical group. Mean incremental follow-up costs per month for patients in the microsurgery group started just > $1000 per month, decreased steadily, and remained < $70 per month by the 10th month of follow-up. Mean incremental follow-up costs per month for patients in the radiosurgery group were <$10 per month for the first few months and thereafter increased to as much as $200 per month. Conclusions Although the total cost of microsurgery is higher due to the costs of hospitalization, follow-up costs for radiosurgery are greater in general. From a societal perspective, radiosurgery is less expensive than microsurgical resection provided that the rate of tumor progression after radiosurgery remains low with long-term follow-up.