Distinct Time Effects of Vaccination on Long-Term Proliferative and IFN-γ–producing T Cell Memory to Smallpox in Humans

Abstract

Residual immunity to the smallpox virus raises key questions about the persistence of long-term immune memory in the absence of antigen, since vaccination ended in 1980. IFN-γ–producing effector–memory and proliferative memory T cells were compared in 79 vaccinees 13–25 yr after their last immunization and in unvaccinated individuals. Only 20% of the vaccinees displayed both immediate IFN-γ–producing effector–memory responses and proliferative memory responses at 6 d; 52.5% showed only proliferative responses; and 27.5% had no detectable vaccinia-specific responses at all. Both responses were mediated by CD4 and CD8 T cells. The vaccinia-specific IFN-γ–producing cells were composed mainly of CD4Pos CD45RANeg CD11aHi CD27Pos and CCR7Neg T cells. Their frequency was low but could be expanded in vitro within 7 d. Time since first immunization affected their persistence: they vanished 45 yr after priming, but proliferative responses remained detectable. The number of recalls did not affect the persistence of residual effector–memory T cells. Programmed revaccination boosted both IFN-γ and proliferative responses within 2 mo of recall, even in vaccinees with previously undetectable residual effector–memory cells. Such long-term maintenance of vaccinia-specific immune memory in the absence of smallpox virus modifies our understanding of the mechanism of persistence of long-term memory to poxviruses and challenges vaccination strategies.