Cyanobacteria-ferrihydrite aggregates, BIF sedimentation and implications for Archaean- Palaeoproterozoic seawater geochemistry

Abstract

Abstract Precambrian banded iron formations (BIFs) are iron- and silica-rich (bio)chemical sediments that are widely believed to have been precipitated by microbial oxidation of dissolved Fe(II). The by-product of these metabolisms – insoluble ferric iron – would have settled through the water column, often as aggregates with the cell biomass. While the mineralogy, composition and physical properties of cell-iron mineral aggregates formed by anaerobic Fe(II)-oxidising photoferrotrophic bacteria have been extensively studied, there are limited studies that characterise cyanobacteria-iron mineral aggregates that formed during oxygenic photosynthesis. This gap in knowledge is important because it impacts sedimentation velocities and the Fe(III) to organic carbon (Corg) ratios in the marine sediment pile. Here, we used a recently introduced approach to precisely measure the sedimentation velocity of cyanobacteria-ferrihydrite aggregates and the Fe(III):Corg ratios of the cyanobacteria-ferrihydrite aggregates over a wide range of pH and initial Fe(II) concentrations under predicted Palaeoproterozoic atmospheric conditions. Our results indicate that it was highly unlikely BIFs formed at pH <7 via chemical oxidation due to the insufficient sedimentation velocity, even at the maximum predicted Fe(II) concentration of 1800 μM with excess oxygen. Instead, large Banded Iron Formation (BIF) deposits, such as those associated with the ca. 2.47 Ga Kuruman Formation in South Africa, would only had been deposited at minimum Fe(II) concentrations of 500 μM at pH 7 or 250 μM at pH 8. The Fe:Corg ratios in cyanobacteria-ferrihydrite sediments formed during initially anoxic Fe(II) oxidation experiments represent the maximum values under each condition because we specifically extracted samples after all Fe(II) was oxidised. The Fe(III) to organic carbon ratio was consistently below 4, which is also the ratio required for dissimilatory Fe(III) reduction (DIR). This result indicates that biomass in this case was in excess, which contradicts the low organic carbon content seen in most BIFs. Thus, we suggest that biomass was either physically separated from ferrihydrite aggregates during sedimentation under the influence of ocean currents and waves, or it was degraded prior to DIR. The mineralogical and geochemical evidences of both oxide and carbonate facies from the Kuruman Iron Formation (IF) suggest that ferrihydrite was most likely the precursor along with a significant initial organic carbon input, supporting the proposed cyanobacterially-mediated BIF depositional model and experimental results.