The Ehrenfest force field: A perspective based on electron density functions

Abstract

The topology of the Ehrenfest force field (EhF) is investigated as a tool for describing local interactions in molecules and intermolecular complexes. The EhF is obtained by integrating the electronic force operator over the coordinates of all but one electron, which requires knowledge of both the electron density and the reduced pair density. For stationary states, the EhF can also be obtained as minus the divergence of the kinetic stress tensor, although this approach leads to well-documented erroneous asymptotic behavior at large distances from the nuclei. It is shown that these pathologies disappear using the electron density functions and that the EhF thus obtained displays the correct behavior in real space, with no spurious critical points or attractors. Therefore, its critical points can be unambiguously obtained and classified. Test cases, including strained molecules, isomerization reactions, and intermolecular interactions, were analyzed. Various chemically relevant facts are highlighted: for example, non-nuclear attractors are generally absent, potential hydrogen–hydrogen interactions are detected in crowded systems, and a bifurcation mechanism is observed in the isomerization of HCN. Moreover, the EhF atomic basins are less charged than those of the electron density. Although integration of the EhF over regions of real space can also be performed to yield the corresponding atomic forces, several numerical drawbacks still need to be solved if electron density functions are to be used for that purpose. Overall, the results obtained support the Ehrenfest force field as a reliable descriptor for the definition of atomic basins and molecular structure.