Physical Mechanisms Driving Enhanced Carbon Sequestration by the Biological Pump Under Climate Warming

Abstract

AbstractAs ocean Carbon Dioxide Removal techniques are being considered, it is critical that they be evaluated against our scientific understanding of the global biological carbon pump. In a recent paper Nowicki et al. (2022, https://doi.org/10.1029/2021GB007083) provide an innovative and comprehensive breakdown of the different mechanistic pathways of carbon sequestration through the present‐day biological pump but then speculate that “These results suggest that ocean carbon storage will weaken as the oceans stratify and the subtropical gyres expand due to anthropogenic climate change.” Essentially, the authors combine their steady state result that oligotrophic subtropical gyres have lower residence times than other areas with the climate change result of these areas increasing under climate warming and extrapolate—assuming “all else is equal”—that the overall ocean will suffer a reduction in carbon sequestration efficiency. Expressing global changes in carbon sequestered by the ocean's biological pump as the summation of local changes in the sequestered carbon, timescale of return to the surface, and biogeographical area, I discuss how all three terms are tightly coupled, and summarize decades of climate change modeling consistently indicating that the global scale physical sequestration response is an increase ‐ in opposition of what one would infer from changes in subtropical area alone.