Analysis of Surgical Salvage After Failure of Primary Therapy in Rectal Cancer: Results From Intergroup Study 0114

Abstract

Purpose: Intergroup Study 0114 was designed to study the effect of various chemotherapy regimens delivered after potentially curative surgical resection of T3, T4, and/or node-positive rectal cancer. A subset analysis was undertaken to investigate the prevalence and influence of salvage therapy among patients with recurrent disease. Patients and Methods: Adjuvant therapy consisted of two cycles of fluorouracil (FU)-based chemotherapy followed by pelvic irradiation with chemotherapy and two more cycles of chemotherapy after radiation therapy. A total of 1,792 patients were entered onto the study and 1,696 were assessable. After a median of 8.9 years of follow-up, 715 patients (42%) had disease recurrence, and an additional 10% died without evidence of disease. Five hundred patients with follow-up information available had a single organ or single site of first recurrence (73.5% of all recurrences). Results: A total of 171 patients (34% of those with a single organ or single site of recurrence) had a potentially curative resection of the metastatic or locally recurrent disease. Single-site first recurrences in the liver, lung, or pelvis occurred in 448 patients (90% of the single-site recurrences), with 159 (35%) of these undergoing surgical resection for attempted cure. Overall survival differed significantly between the resected and nonresected groups (P < .0001), with overall 5-year probabilities of .27 and .06, respectively. Controlling for worst performance status at the time of recurrence does not alter this relationship. Patients who underwent salvage surgery had significantly increased survival (P < .001) for each site. Conclusion: Attempted surgical salvage of rectal cancer recurrence is performed commonly in the United States. The chance of a long-term cure with such intervention is approximately 27%.