Experimental Verification of 1D-Simulation Method of Water Hammer Induced in Two Series-Connected Pipes of Different Diameters: Determination of the Pressure Wave Speed

Abstract

This paper presents the results of laboratory tests of water hammer phenomenon induced in two series-connected copper pipes with different diameters (a diameter ratio of 1:1.25) by a quick-closing valve installed at the end of the simple upstream tank–pipeline–valve system. Test results were compared with calculations made with the use of various friction loss models incorporated in a one-dimensional model based on a method of characteristics. The calculation takes into consideration quasi-steady and unsteady friction models as well as a special discretization procedure of the solution domain that ensures the elimination of numerical diffusion in the numerical scheme. The main attention was paid to determining the value of the pressure wave speed in the pipes, which has a significant influence on the compliance between the calculations and the experimental results of the pressure amplitudes and wave frequencies. Two methods of determining the wave speed were proposed and evaluated based on the measurements. The results presented in this article indicate that the use of the proposed procedure instead of the classic formulas for determining the pressure wave speed gives the desired correspondence between the frequencies of the measured and calculated waves. Calculation examples made with the use of different friction models showed that application of the developed procedure for discretization of the solution domain and the method used for determining the wave speed opened the possibility of reliable verification of these models, free of numerical errors and frequency discrepancies between the computational and measured wave.