Affiliation:
1. Department of English Studies, University of Graz, 8010 Graz, Austria
Abstract
Background: Experts are a favorite source of information in the news media as they have the ability to provide balanced and authoritative comments on important issues. However, two factors cast doubt on the extent to which such experts can actually provide balanced information: conflicts of interest and areas of expertise. In this paper, we analyze the use of expert voices during the COVID pandemic in two Austrian broadsheet papers. Methods: We examine the use of reporting verbs employed to indicate the journalists’ stance towards the expert comments as well as the relationship of those comments to the experts’ fields of expertise and to any potential conflicts of interest. Results: Our analysis shows that the media uncritically reported experts that had considerable conflicts of interest, while others were permitted to comment on topics far outside their particular fields. Conclusions: In the absence of journalistic scrutiny, distance, and context, both of these practices are likely to have led audiences to take the experts’ comments at face value and therefore to have embraced unbalanced information that amplified official narratives, to the exclusion of alternative voices.
Subject
Medical Assisting and Transcription,Medical Terminology
Reference120 articles.
1. The interaction between experts and journalists in news journalism;Albaek;Journalism,2011
2. Albaek, Erik, Van Dalen, Arjen, Jebril, Nael, and De Vreese, Claes H. (2014). Political Journalism in Comparative Perspective, Cambridge University Press.
3. Experts in the mass media: Researchers as sources in Danish daily newspapers 1961–2001;Albaek;Journal of Mass Communication Quarterly,2003
4. A serological assay to detect SARS-CoV-2 seroconversion in humans;Amanat;Nature Medicine,2020
5. Anders, Theo (2023, September 26). Experte Sprenger hat genug von der Corona-Taskforce. Available online: https://www.derstandard.at/story/2000116710462/experte-spenger-hat-genug-von-der-corona-taskforce.