Comparison of nonparametric estimators of the expected number of recurrent events

Abstract

AbstractWe compare the performance of nonparametric estimators for the mean number of recurrent events and provide a systematic overview for different recurrent event settings. The mean number of recurrent events is an easily interpreted marginal feature often used for treatment comparisons in clinical trials. Incomplete observations, dependencies between successive events, terminating events acting as competing risk, or gaps between at risk periods complicate the estimation. We use survival multistate models to represent different complex recurrent event situations, profiting from recent advances in nonparametric estimation for non‐Markov multistate models, and explain several estimators by using multistate intensity processes, including the common Nelson–Aalen‐type estimators with and without competing mortality. In addition to building on estimation of state occupation probabilities in non‐Markov models, we consider a simple extension of the Nelson–Aalen estimator by allowing for dependence on the number of prior recurrent events. We pay particular attention to the assumptions required for the censoring mechanism, one issue being that some settings require the censoring process to be entirely unrelated while others allow for state‐dependent or event‐driven censoring. We conducted extensive simulation studies to compare the estimators in various complex situations with recurrent events. Our practical example deals with recurrent chronic obstructive pulmonary disease exacerbations in a clinical study, which will also be used to illustrate two‐sample‐inference using resampling.