What Is New in Stage 3 of the 2019 Revised Association Research Circulation Osseous Staging System of Osteonecrosis of the Femoral Head: A Relationship to Bone Resorption

Abstract

Purpose The aim of the study is to evaluate the stage 3 findings of the 2019 revision of the Association Research Circulation Osseous (ARCO) staging system for osteonecrosis of the femoral head between 3A and 3B and the relationship with bone resorption area. Materials and Methods We retrospectively enrolled 87 patients with ARCO stage 3 osteonecrosis of the femoral head, divided into stage 3A (n = 73) and 3B (n = 14). The revised stage 3 findings included subchondral fracture, fracture in necrotic portion, and flattening of the femoral head and were compared between stage 3A and 3B. The association between these findings and the causative features of bone resorption area was also evaluated. Results All stage 3 cases had subchondral fractures. In stage 3A, these fractures were generated by crescent sign (41.1%) and by fibrovascular reparative zone in 58.9%; however, in stage 3B, fibrovascular reparative zone generated 92.9% of these fractures and crescent sign only 7.1% with statistical significance (P = 0.034). Necrotic portion fracture was noted in 36.7% and femoral head flattening was observed in 14.9% of all stage 3. Necrotic portion fracture (92.9% vs 26.0%) and femoral head flattening (71.4% vs 4.1%) were observed more frequently in stage 3B than 3A (P < 0.001). Almost all subchondral fractures by fibrovascular reparative zone (96.4%) and necrotic portion fracture (96.9%), and all femoral head flattening was presented with bone resorption area with expanding areas. Conclusions The ARCO stage 3 descriptions reflect severity in this order: subchondral fracture, necrotic portion fracture, and femoral head flattening. More severe findings are usually associated with expanding bone resorption areas.