Operative Fractures of the Phalangeal Head and Neck in Children—Does Open Reduction Affect Outcomes?

Abstract

Background: Closed reduction percutaneous pinning of displaced pediatric phalangeal head and neck fractures is preferred to prevent malunion and loss of motion and function. However, open reduction is required for irreducible fractures and open injuries. We hypothesize that osteonecrosis is more common in open injuries than closed injuries that require either open reduction or closed reduction percutaneous pinning. Methods: Retrospective chart review of 165 phalangeal head and neck fractures treated surgically with pin fixation at a single tertiary pediatric trauma center from 2007 to 2017. Fractures were stratified as open injuries (OI), closed injuries undergoing open reduction (COR), or closed injuries treated with closed reduction (CCR). The groups were compared using Pearson χ2 tests and ANOVA. Two group comparisons were made with Student t test. Results: There were 17 OI fractures, 14 COR fractures, and 136 CCR fractures. Crush injury was the predominant mechanism in OI versus COR and CCR groups. The average time from injury to surgery was 1.6 days for OI, 20.4 days for COR, and 10.4 days for CCR. The average follow-up was 86.5 days (range, 0 to 1204). The osteonecrosis rate differed between the OI versus COR and OI versus CCR groups (71% for OI, 7.1% for COR, and 1.5% for CCR). Rates of coronal malangulation >15 degrees differed between the OI and COR or CCR groups, but the 2 closed groups did not differ. Outcomes were defined using Al-Qattan’s system; CCR had the most excellent and fewest poor outcomes. One OI patient underwent partial finger amputation. One CCR patient had rotational malunion but declined derotational osteotomy. Conclusions: Open phalangeal head and neck fractures have more concomitant digital injuries and postoperative complications compared with injuries closed on presentation, regardless of whether the fracture underwent open or closed reduction. Although osteonecrosis occurred in all 3 cohorts, it was most frequent in open injuries. This study allows surgeons to discuss rates of osteonecrosis and resultant complications with families whose child presents with phalangeal head and neck fractures that are indicated for surgical treatment. Level of Evidence: Therapeutic, Level III.